IIT Expert

Precomputed result

The five-unit network of the IIT 4.0 paper in state ABcde specifies 23 distinctions with different purviews

Substrate The Fig 7 network (see iit:result/albantakis-2023-fig7a-active) in a different state: unit E is OFF instead of ON. PyPhi ships the substrate, with the weights supplied by the authors, as pyphi.examples.iit4_2023_fig7_substrate.
State (1, 1, −1, −1, −1) — ABcde, units A, B ON
φs 0.24902638133897767
Minimum partition A directed partition severing 14 of the 25 connections; the script lists them. The same under both formulations.
Formalism iit-4.0-2026
PyPhi 2.0.0rc4
Script albantakis-2023-fig7b-inactive.py

Albantakis et al. (2023) turn unit E from ON to OFF to show that an inactive unit still contributes to the Φ-structure: the number of distinctions stays the same, but their purviews and φd change, and so do the relations.

quantity Fig 7B 2023 2026
complex ABcde ABcde ABcde
φs 1.31 1.3133 0.2490
distinctions 23 of 31 23 23
relations 13111 13498 13498
Φ 18.55 19.3169 19.3169

The relation counts and Φ differ from the figure because of a tie, described below. The distinctions match the figure's list in mechanism, purviews, states, and φd to four decimals (for example Bc → c | aB with φd = 0.0234 and Bcde → c | a with 0.0020), except that the cause purview of cde is b where the figure lists c. Σφd = 4.5395 and Σφr = 14.7774.

The cause purview of the mechanism cde is tied: the readings b and c, both in state −1, give the same φd = 0.0132 and are both congruent with the system's specified cause state. The two readings give different Φ-structures, because the cause purview determines which other distinctions cde overlaps.

resolution of the cde tie cause purview relations Σφr Φ
maximal Φ (S1 Text) b 13498 14.7774 19.3169
figure c 13111 14.0170 18.5565

S1 Text of the paper ("Resolving ties in the IIT algorithm") states that ties in the cause or effect of a distinction "may be resolved at the level of the cause–effect structure, by selecting the z*c/e that maximizes the system's structure integrated information Φ". The reading b does that, and it is the one PyPhi 2.0 selects, so the canon reports it. The figure's values come from the reading c; PyPhi attributes them to the enumeration order of the 2023 code. The script substitutes c and prints that result as well, which reproduces the figure's relation count and Φ (the figure truncates Φ to 18.55).

The paper states that in panel B "φs changes only slightly" and that Φ is lower than in panel A. Under the 2023 formulation φs rises from 1.11 to 1.31; under the current formulation it falls from 0.48 to 0.25. Φ is lower than in panel A (22.27) under either resolution of the tie.

The script uses the default configuration of each formulation. To reproduce, run the script with uv, which installs PyPhi 2.0.0rc4 for the run:

uv run --with "pyphi==2.0.0rc4" python canon/albantakis-2023-fig7b-inactive.py

Sources