---
identifier: iit:result/comolatti-2025-space-grid
title: A non-directed seven-unit grid specifies reflexive distinctions over contiguous mechanisms
vetted_by: "Matteo Grasso"
formalism: iit-4.0-2026
summary: >-
  The time grid of Comolatti, Grasso & Tononi (2025) with symmetric lateral
  connections, all units OFF, specifies 79 distinctions. All 28 with
  contiguous mechanisms are reflexive, with cause and effect over the same
  units, and they reproduce the spots S1–S4 of the paper's Figure 12B
  (cde → d, bcde → cd, cdef → de, bcdef → cde). Of the 51 distinctions with
  non-contiguous mechanisms, 18 are not reflexive. Computed with PyPhi, with
  wedge tripartitions of mechanisms as in the time grid entry.
substrate: >-
  Seven binary units abcdefg in a line. Each unit has a self-connection
  (weight 0.3) and a connection of 0.2 to each neighbour, in both
  directions. Each unit endorses the grid's current state: an input is
  excitatory when its unit and the target agree in that state and inhibitory
  otherwise, through a logistic with determinism 1 and no threshold. The
  paper does not print the weights of its non-directed grid; these are the
  time grid's weights with the two lateral connections made equal.
state: "(0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0) — abcdefg, all units OFF"
phi: 0.008815681213738526
mip: >-
  The bipartition into {a, b, c, d} and {e, f, g}, cutting the connections
  in both directions between them. Of those, only d → e and e → d (weight
  0.2 each) are present.
pyphi_version: 2.0.0rc4
script: comolatti-2025-space-grid.py
see_also:
  - iit:result/comolatti-2025-time-grid
  - iit:measure/phi-s
sources:
  - ref: iit:ref/comolatti-2025
    at: >-
      Discussion, "Similarities and differences between the experience of
      time and space"; Figure 12B
---

Comolatti, Grasso & Tononi (2025) contrast the directed grids they propose
as the substrate of temporal flow with non-directed grids, the substrate
proposed for spatial extendedness. A non-directed grid specifies
distinctions that are reflexive, "having cause and effect over the same
elements (usually a subset of the mechanism elements)" (Discussion). Figure
12B shows four such distinctions, the spots S1–S4, in a seven-unit
non-directed grid. The paper treats the grid as part of a larger complex, so
its claims concern the structure's distinctions, not the grid's own φ_s.

| spot, Fig 12B | mechanism | cause \| effect, paper | computed | φ_d |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| S3 | cde | d \| d | d \| d | 0.07011 |
| S1 | bcde | cd \| cd | cd \| cd | 0.09370 |
| S2 | cdef | de \| de | de \| de | 0.09370 |
| S4 | bcdef | cde \| cde | cde \| cde | 0.06172 |

All 28 contiguous distinctions are reflexive. Single units and pairs specify
themselves (a → a \| a, ab → ab \| ab). From order 3 to order 6, each
contiguous mechanism specifies its interior units, the mechanism minus its
two end units (abc → b \| b, abcdef → bcde \| bcde). The whole grid specifies
abcdefg → bdf \| bdf, which is reflexive but skips c and e; Figure 12B draws
this distinction without labelling its purviews. The script prints all 28.

| quantity | computed |
|---|---|
| distinctions | 79 |
| reflexive distinctions | 61 |
| distinctions with contiguous mechanisms | 28 |
| reflexive, contiguous | 28 |

Of the 51 distinctions with non-contiguous mechanisms, 18 are not
reflexive. In most of them the effect purview shifts one unit toward the gap
in the mechanism (abd → ac \| bc, abde → ace \| acd), with φ_d from 0.016 to
0.045. The paper's caption states that reflexivity "also holds for the other
distinctions that compose the cause-effect structure"; with these weights
that holds for the contiguous distinctions, which are the ones the figure
draws.

The result depends on the lateral weight. With self-connection 0.3 and no
threshold, every lateral weight from 0.05 to 0.20 gives the same 28
contiguous purviews. From 0.25 upward, purviews spread beyond the interior
units, first for single units (a → a \| ab at 0.25) and then for mechanisms
of order 3 and 4 (abc → ab \| abc at 0.35).
Adding an inhibitory connection to second neighbours makes most
non-contiguous distinctions reflexive without changing the contiguous ones
up to a weight of −0.07; at −0.1 the order-6 distinctions become
non-reflexive (abcdef → abcde \| bcde).

The script sets PyPhi's `WEDGE_TRIPARTITION` mechanism partition scheme, as
in the time grid entry, and otherwise uses the default configuration of the
IIT 4.0 (2026) formulation. In the all-OFF state every unit agrees with every
other, so the endorsement leaves all weights excitatory.

To reproduce, run the script with uv, which installs PyPhi 2.0.0rc4 for the run:

```
uv run --with "pyphi==2.0.0rc4" python canon/comolatti-2025-space-grid.py
```
