---
identifier: iit:result/albantakis-2023-fig6d-lattice
title: The specialized lattice of the IIT 4.0 paper is one complex with 27 distinctions and over 1.5 million relations
vetted_by: "Matteo Grasso"
formalism: iit-4.0-2026
summary: >-
  The specialized six-unit lattice of Albantakis et al. (2023), Fig 6D, in
  state Abcdef is a single complex whose Φ-structure has 27 of 63 possible
  distinctions and 1536628 relations, Φ = 12394.62. One distinction, ef, has
  a tied cause purview. Resolved as the paper's S1 Text prescribes, by
  maximizing Φ, it gives these values; the figure's 1537080 relations and
  Φ = 11451.99 come from the other reading. φ_s is 0.49 under the current
  formulation and 1.05 under the 2023 formulation (figure: 1.05).
substrate: >-
  Six binary units A–F with states in {−1, 1}, each a logistic of its
  weighted inputs (Eq 60) with k = 4, all-to-all connected. Each unit has one
  strong input of weight 0.7 (E→A, A→B, F→C, C→D, D→E, B→F), one
  intermediate input of 0.12 (D→A, E→B, B→C, F→D, C→E, A→F), one input of
  0.09 (A→A, C→B, D→C, B→D, E→E, F→F), and weak inputs of 0.03 from the
  other three units, including itself for B, C, and D. PyPhi ships the
  substrate, with the weights supplied by the authors, as
  `pyphi.examples.iit4_2023_fig6d_substrate`.
state: "(1, −1, −1, −1, −1, −1) — Abcdef, unit A ON"
phi: 0.48563247586005204
mip: >-
  A directed partition severing 20 of the 36 connections; the script lists
  them. The same under both formulations.
pyphi_version: 2.0.0rc4
script: albantakis-2023-fig6d-lattice.py
see_also:
  - iit:measure/phi-s
  - iit:result/albantakis-2023-fig6c-copy-cycle
  - iit:result/albantakis-2023-fig6e-near-maximal
sources:
  - ref: iit:ref/albantakis-2023b
    at: >-
      Fig 6D and its caption; Results and discussion, "Specialized lattices
      and Φ-structures with high structure integrated information"; S1 Text,
      "Resolving ties in the IIT algorithm"
  - ref: iit:ref/mayner-2026
    at: '§3.2 "Example 2: Complexes"'
---

Albantakis et al. (2023) use this lattice to show that specialized units
with overlapping inputs and outputs can constitute a large complex that
unfolds into a rich Φ-structure. Many subsets have positive φ_s, but the
full six-unit system is the maximal substrate and excludes them all.

| quantity | Fig 6D | 2023 | 2026 |
|---|---|---|---|
| complex | Abcdef | Abcdef | Abcdef |
| φ_s | 1.05 | 1.0539 | 0.4856 |
| distinctions | 27 of 63 | 27 | 27 |
| Σφ_d | 6.2361 | 6.2362 | 6.2362 |
| relations | 1537080 | 1536628 | 1536628 |
| Σφ_r | 11445.7506 | 12388.3808 | 12388.3808 |
| Φ | 11451.98 | 12394.6170 | 12394.6170 |

The relation counts, Σφ_r, and Φ differ from the figure because of a tie,
described below. The figure does not list the distinctions; the script
prints all 27. The six first-order distinctions each have φ_d = 0.8392 (for
example A → E | B), and the highest-order distinction is
bcdef → bcf | acdef with φ_d = 0.0871. The full mechanism Abcdef specifies
no distinction.

The cause purview of the mechanism ef is tied: the readings ab and cd give
the same φ_d = 0.0201 and are both congruent with the system's specified
cause state. The two readings give different Φ-structures, because the cause
purview determines which other distinctions ef overlaps.

| resolution of the ef tie | cause purview | relations | Σφ_r | Φ |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| maximal Φ (S1 Text) | cd | 1536628 | 12388.3808 | 12394.6170 |
| figure | ab | 1537080 | 11445.7506 | 11451.9868 |

S1 Text of the paper ("Resolving ties in the IIT algorithm") states that
ties in the cause or effect of a distinction "may be resolved at the level
of the cause–effect structure, by selecting the z*c/e that maximizes the
system's structure integrated information Φ". The reading cd does that, and
it is the one PyPhi 2.0 selects, so the canon reports it. S1 Text adds that
the maximizing reading "will generally" be the one supporting the most
relations; here it supports fewer relations (452 fewer) but a larger Σφ_r.
The figure's values come from the reading ab; PyPhi attributes them to the
enumeration order of the 2023 code. The script substitutes ab and prints
that result as well, which reproduces the figure's relation count and Φ.

Under the current formulation the full system is still the only complex,
with φ_s = 0.49. Mayner et al. (2026, §3.2) reanalyse this lattice with the
intrinsic information requirement and report that it is a complex at
K = 4, and that intrinsic differentiation affects φ_s only for K above about
2.84.

The script uses the default configuration of each formulation. Relations
are summed analytically; the figure's 1.5 million relations are not
enumerated. To reproduce, run the script with uv, which installs PyPhi 2.0.0rc4 for the run
(several minutes on a multicore machine):

```
uv run --with "pyphi==2.0.0rc4" python canon/albantakis-2023-fig6d-lattice.py
```
